The Ferda Room: McDavid's perfect 21 and Toronto's six-game hole
Edmonton's 1-0 win in Toronto was the week in one game, Florida won three straight, and the Room went 3-3 on its locks.

Edmonton walked into Toronto on Saturday with Mike Babcock behind its bench for the first time since the Leafs fired him, and won 1-0 on a Devon Levi shutout. Connor McDavid's point streak is at 21 games in 21. Toronto has lost six straight and six straight at home, and sits last in the Atlantic.
The room agrees McDavid is the story. It splits on whether Florida's three straight wins are a turn or a soft week.
The big one: McDavid's 21 and Toronto's six
Marcus Lind — What the numbers say
The number is 50, McDavid's point total through 21 games, 11 goals and 39 assists, per NHL data, with a point in every one of them. Only four players in league history got to 50 that fast.
He's doing it on a $12.5 million cap hit through 2027-28, about 12 percent of this year's $104 million ceiling. Edmonton is 15-3-3, hasn't lost a road game in regulation by our count, and runs a 32.9 percent power play.
Toronto's sheet is the other half. The Leafs are 0-5 in their last five at minus-13 by our count, 4-9-1 at home, and Oliver Ekman-Larsson is 11 games without a point at 18.5 minutes a night. The gap on Saturday was one goal. The gap on paper is a season.
Gord Tremblay — Where it goes from here
Jim Hiller was hired in June to replace Craig Berube. Five months later he's coaching a team that has lost six straight in regulation and six straight in its own building, and nobody has written a word about his seat. In Toronto, that silence lasts about a week.
The read: the market decides this, not the GM. Toronto is 8-12-2, and Saturday was its best game in weeks, which is the sentence every coach hears right before it stops mattering. Babcock lasted 23 games into his last Toronto season. Hiller is at 22. I'd treat the quiet as smoke, not fire, for exactly one more week.
Sully — The grade and the grievance
Look, Toronto got outshot, scored nothing, and the coach they fired seven years ago came back and beat them with a goalie who'd never had a shutout. Devon Levi stopped 19, and there are Zambonis in that building that have seen more rubber.
McDavid set up the only goal and made it 21 for 21. I had him ending the streak two weeks ago, so I'm on the bandwagon now with a seat belt. Toronto is 1-6 as a home underdog by our closing-line count, which means Vegas knew before the Leafs did.
Grade: A for Edmonton, F-minus for Toronto. One concession: Stolarz stopped 22 and deserved a tie. In Toronto that's called a moral victory, and they're undefeated in those.
Gord Tremblay — Three from the notebook
1. The Michkov report had a shelf life of about four hours. Weekes floated Tuesday that Matvei Michkov wants a fresh start away from Philadelphia. The pushback landed the same day: no formal request, no plan to move him, "not there yet." Grade: Reported.
The read: the minutes are the story, ten goals in 20 games at under 16 minutes a night, per NHL data, in the last year of his entry-level deal. I had the full file on Wednesday.
2. Karlsson to Carolina is real and it's a January story. LeBrun has Pittsburgh selling, Karlsson's full no-move in the way, and his camp meeting Dubas in the new year. Grade: Reported.
The read: Karlsson has 19 points in 19 games at 23.6 minutes, per NHL data, and Carolina, 4-1 in its last five at plus-13 by our count, doesn't need him yet. That timeline is why my lock died.
3. Rakell said no to Chicago, if you believe a podcast. Yandle said he heard Rickard Rakell turned down a trade to the Blackhawks on Pittsburgh's West Coast trip. Nobody else has it. Grade: Smoke.
The read: Pittsburgh is 2-3 in its last five at minus-7, by our count, and still hasn't moved a regular, because every veteran with protection decides when the sale starts. The GM just holds the sign.
Marcus Lind — The number
The number: $14 million. That's the gap between next season's $113.5 million ceiling and the $127.5 million the league floated for 2028-29. The league and the union meet in the new year to smooth it, and the summer that jump lands is the summer McDavid's deal expires.
I did the math on what smoothing takes out of his next contract: a little, and nobody in Edmonton minds.
Sign him now / Wait: Matvei Michkov
-
Sign him now: 46 goals in his first two seasons, 10 in 20 this year, and a ceiling that climbs $9.5 million next summer. The share of the cap he costs today is the smallest it will ever be.
-
Wait: he's under 16 minutes a night for a coach who scratched him from a playoff game. You don't hand term to a player the bench doesn't trust yet, and a team at 18 points in 22 games isn't buying a window this year.
-
My call: a two-year bridge, and the Flyers go first, because it buys both sides the one thing they're short on, which is evidence. I'll put a number on it when a 21-year-old with his production signs this season; until then a projection is a guess wearing a tie.
Sully — The grievance
Look, Boston gave up five goals in 35 minutes to Montreal on Thursday and six to Minnesota on Saturday, both at the Garden. Eleven goals in two home games.
Swayman got pulled Thursday after four goals on 17 shots, and he's at .870 over his last five starts, per NHL data, a week after stopping 40 of 41 against Florida. That's not a goalie, that's a weather system.
Saturday, Boston finally scored on the power play and Jeannot and Foligno were throwing hands three seconds later. You get one nice thing and start a fight about it. Zadorov took 14 minutes in the third, McAvoy went minus-4 in his own building, and Zadorov's penalty minutes outscored the Bruins.
Grade: F. Marcus will tell you Boston still has 27 points. I have eyes, and they hurt.
Kept off the sheet: Cam Fowler, St. Louis. Thirteen straight games without a point at 20.8 minutes a night, per NHL data. Saturday his one contribution was the high stick that handed Florida the power play Brady Tkachuk scored on. He finally made the sheet. Wrong column.
Fight of the week: Jeannot and Foligno, Saturday, three seconds after a Bruins power-play goal. Both asked, both answered, and I'm calling it a draw because the only thing that lost was the momentum.
Tommy Kessler — Campus minute
Providence won the weekend I said would sort Hockey East, beating Merrimack 4-2 at home Friday on Logan Sawyer's late tiebreaker, then going into Lawler Rink and winning 5-0. That's a sweep of a ranked team by the most complete club in the league right now.
The poll took my lock away: Michigan stayed No. 2 behind Wisconsin and Michigan State dropped to fourth after its split with BU. Then Ohio State beat Wisconsin 2-1 Saturday, and Maine answered Friday's 0-0 shootout loss by beating Vermont 3-1.
The prospect the NHL crowd should know is Carter Bear, tied for the AHL scoring lead at 18 points in 13 games while Detroit's offense can't find the net.
Meg Halloran — The W minute
The Americans put 85 shots on Denmark in a 14-0 quarterfinal, a Women's Worlds record. Canada outshot Czechia 41-16 and needed Renata Fast to win 3-2. Both play today's semifinals in Herning, the U.S. against Finland and Canada against Sweden, with gold Monday at 1 p.m. ET.
Back home, the PWHL named its four expansion teams: the Detroit Clutch, Hamilton Havoc, San Jose Sea Lions and Vegas Vanguards, with season four opening Dec. 5. Detroit won the launch. On campus, Mercyhurst shut out No. 7 Penn State 5-0.
The W read: 41 shots and two goals against Czechia is a finishing problem, and those don't fix themselves in a semifinal. Sweden will sit back and wait for it.
Pabs — The Panthers table
Three wins in a row, and the one I'd keep is Thursday. Boston buried the cats 4-1 on Sunday with Swayman stopping 40 of 41. Then Markstrom stopped 36 in Columbus and Florida climbed out of a 4-1 hole against Detroit on two Lundell goals and Reinhart's 200th as a Panther.
Saturday the Tkachuk brothers handled St. Louis 4-1 on the night their dad went into the Hall. Florida is 12-7-2 with 26 points and 7-5 on the road, by our count. Matthew Tkachuk's point streak is at seven, per NHL data.
Maurice has Barkov and Marchand within two weeks. In Estero, the Everblades beat South Carolina 3-1 on Saturday and sit 8-1-0, first in the South at 16 points (box score).
The week: Dallas tonight at 8 on the back half of a back-to-back, McDavid and the Oilers in Sunrise on Tuesday, then Buffalo on Saturday.
-
Marcus: Reinhart played 23 minutes against Detroit and 17.2 against St. Louis, a 5.8-minute drop, per NHL data. That's not a demotion; it's what a 2-0 lead after seven minutes buys a coach who needs to rest his center.
-
Gord: Tuesday is the one Panthers game the Canadian room will watch this month. The Canadian read on the Panthers is still the team that beats theirs in June, and Tuesday is the audition for the next one.
-
Sully: Gustav Forsling ended a 10-game pointless run Thursday with the goal that saved the night, then played 19.9 minutes Saturday and vanished again. Buddy, you proved you can do it. Now do it on purpose.
-
Kessler: Sandis Vilmanis went from 13 minutes against Detroit to 14.2 with a point against St. Louis, per NHL data, a week after Tom Wilson boarded him. The kid stayed in the lineup, and that's the whole story of his November.
The Room's locks
Last week's calls, with the receipts:
-
Pabs: wrong. Florida beat Detroit 5-4 after trailing 4-1 until the last 18 seconds of the second. He said it wouldn't be close. It was the closest game of the week.
-
Marcus: right. Quinn Hughes is still unsigned, and Guerin said there's "nothing really to talk about right now."
-
Gord: wrong. Pittsburgh didn't trade a regular. Karlsson's no-move and a January meeting with Dubas were the receipt.
-
Sully: right. McDavid's streak reached 21 on Saturday, exactly where he called it.
-
Kessler: wrong. Michigan stayed No. 2 in Monday's USCHO poll. Michigan State fell to fourth.
-
Meg: right. Canada went 4-0 in Group B with a 26-1 goal difference, and the U.S. went 4-0 by a combined 31-2.
Season records: Pabs 3-4 · Marcus 5-2 · Gord 5-2 · Sully 3-4 · Kessler 4-3 · Meg 4-3.
And this week's calls:
-
Pabs: Florida beats Edmonton on Tuesday in Sunrise, and Reinhart scores.
-
Marcus: Michkov is still a Flyer next Sunday with no extension signed. The bridge comes later.
-
Gord: Dylan Larkin is still a Red Wing next Sunday. The Thanksgiving timeline holds.
-
Sully: McDavid gets a point in Sunrise on Tuesday. 22 for 22, and I'm done betting against the man.
-
Kessler: Wisconsin stays No. 1 in Monday's USCHO poll despite the Ohio State loss.
-
Meg: Monday's gold-medal game is decided by one goal, and the U.S. wins it.
Where they split
The week's real disagreement is whether Florida's three straight wins mean anything. It's Pabs against Sully.
-
Pabs: Yes. You win a division game from 4-1 down and you learn something about the room. Three wins three different ways, and Barkov isn't back yet.
-
Sully: Columbus, Detroit and St. Louis have 53 points between them in 59 games, and Florida needed 36 saves and a three-goal comeback to beat them. Beat Edmonton Tuesday and I'll call it a turn. Until then it's a soft week with good lighting.
Last word: Meg Halloran
The United States and Canada have allowed four goals in eight games between them, and if both get through today, by Monday night one of them will have lost anyway. That's the Worlds. Thirty-six years of the same two teams, and it never stops being the best game of the year.
The men's-hockey guys will discover the PWHL again in April. The rest of us will be in front of a screen at 1 p.m. ET Monday, finding out whether 41 shots on Czechia was a warning or a fluke.




